Honestly the only way to have a "proven map" is to use a dyno with an AFR for that particular quad. One my friend's quad we had a 450CP with Timbo porting, and used one of Tim's recommended map. The map was too rich and the engine seized in the Oregon dunes last year. This is no fault of Tim's. He specifically says the maps are just to get you running, until you can tune the engine properly. We didn't do that, and a lot of money was lost. Now she is back to running an ASSO piston, because she just can't afford another CP. This could have been avoided for less than $100 and one hour of dyno time with a good "map artist".
Mapping is pretty easy, as you only have to get a few key points correct then blend the rest. The throttle limiter screw is a great tool, because you can set it to only allow for a 25%, then a 50%, and 100% throttle opening, so you know exactly where to tweak the map, just hold the throttle wide open against the pre-setup screw during each dyno run.
Many people associate dynos with making a bunch of horsepower and that they are for bragging only. Honestly, I don't care what numbers I get, I just want the engine to safely take whatever I want to throw at it.
I can't say it enough.... Dyno-dyno-dyno! I am only 30 minutes over the Oregon border, plan for a weekend, bring your quads out in running condition (at least idling) and we can get them right. It will just take a little coordination with the dyno operator, and a bit of cash.
James,
I have watched while you have quoted the above statement many times to people. I believe that you have scared quite a few as well. Let me tell you one thing that I know that is proven. Anyone who would use a sand testing ground on a brand new motor wide open in 4th & 5th gear before the rings have seated does not know enough about motors for me to take advice from. End of point. I have seen motors melt down that were broken in and with a proper AFR and dynoed that blow in the conditions you ride in ONLY. I have riden new motors (after break in) for months without a proper tune with no adverse effects. You ride only in the sand, that is by far the worst environment for a motor. Not everyone does the same. I ride trails and don't see the loads you do in the sand. I have also properly tuned a motor with an AFR meter and some hard riding such as C27 mentions above. A dyno is not absolutely needed for tuning a motor. It does put a load on the motor while you get AFR readings, but I can do the same thing with a portable AFR meter while riding. Yes it's harder, but I save alot of money and can dial it in before ever going to the dyno.
I also have another tip for you, throw an oil pressure gauge on your bike while you ride in the dunes. You may find out that 1 quart of oil is not enough to keep full pressure on the motor while you are riding. Also, don't forget that engine oil is a coolant as well. Would you run your bike with 3/4 of the coolant as well?
Ken